1. Rating
 
  Technical quality

    4: Contents are mostly correct. Some improvements suggested below.
    
  Originality

    3: No significantly new ideas, but good analysis of current state
      
  Editorial quality

    5: Clear, understandable and easy to read

  Overall grade (overall, how do you rate this paper?)

    4: Very good
  
  Confidence (how confident are you about this review?)

    1: This is a completely new subject to me; I made educated guesses

2. Detailed comments

  2a. Technical quality

      In this paper are examined the differences of 
      ad-hoc wireless network and the problems occuring during the initial 
      setup of a security association. In addition, paper provides a method
      called "Physical Contact" to guarantee the reliable first connect
      between two devices for subsequent secure communication. Questions
      considered are how to indetify other peers and authenticate their claims,
      how can be trusted the strangers and how to build up the basic trust and
      exchange secrecy for subsequent secure communication in an open envi-
      ronment.

      Strengths of the paper are that it is easy to read and it gives a
      good introduction to the central concepts of the topic.
      Weakness of the paper is that it is quite short-spoken. The topic is
      such practical that it would not be difficult to add few more detailed
      examples.

      Paper provides a good survey of the state of the art at the
      topic of physical contact in ad-hoc wireless networks.


  2b. Originality

      I think that some of the ideas presented in the paper are new.


  2c. Editorial quality

      Abstract describes the contents of the paper well. 
      The Introduction section gives a practical example of the topic and
      introduces the questions that arises from that. It also explains well 
      the contents of the paper.

      -(section 2, Demonstrative Identification) "callee" ?

      -Only picture provided is about very general and know concept
      but nothing is shown in pictures about the solutions that are examined 
      in the paper.

      -Three and a half pages is a bit shortish survey.