----------------------------------------------------------------------- Evaluation Form T-79.5202 Spring 2006 ----------------------------------------------------------------------- N.B. This form is in English for the benefit of those students who do not speak Finnish. Please feel free to give your comments in Finnish, if that is the language of the original report. For the criteria, not all values from 1-6 have been given a verbal interpretation. Do not let that stop you from using the intermediate values. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Report ID: Please evaluate the following criteria on a scale from 1-6: Correctness of the solution: 6 = Excellent work, clearly correct results and correctness well motivated, interesting results 4 = Good work, correct results, correctness not too well justified 3 = Mostly good work, some minor errors 1 = There are serious problems with the correctness of the solution How suitable is the proposed solution to the problem: 6 = Very suitable, can be generalized / is particularly efficient / is very clear 4 = Suitable, solves the problem in a reasonable fashion 2 = Barely suitable, is obviously unnecessarily complicated / inefficient 1 = Does not solve the problem at hand Reporting results and repeatability of the experiment: 6 = The experiments and results have been reported in a very clear manner and the experiments could be repeated easily 4 = The method and results have been reported in a sufficient manner 3 = The results have been well reported, the methods are somewhat unclearly or insufficiently described for repeating the experiment 1 = The results are completely unintelligible and the experiments could not possibly be repeated with the given information Clarity of the report: language and structure 6 = Excellent 4 = Good 3 = Adequate 1 = Bad Overall: 6 = An excellent report 5 = A very good report 4 = A good report 3 = A satisfactory report 2 = A somewhat deficient report 1 = A completely useless report How certain are you of your evaluation? 6 = Very certain 4 = Fairly certain 3 = Somewhat uncertain 1 = Very uncertain ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Anonymous reviewer comments to the author: Please give a couple of constructive suggestions that would have improved the report. Here you may also justify your evaluation above. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Comments to the lecturer: Here you can send comments about the report to the lecturer. These will not be forwarded to the author.